Most advice about preparing for 1:1s assumes you have half an hour. You don't. Your 1:1 is at 3:00 and it's 2:55 and you just got out of a different meeting. This is the real question: what's the best possible 1:1 you can prepare for in five minutes?
Turns out: most of one. Here's what to do with those five minutes.
Minute 1 — Open last week's notes. Find the loose thread.
Before anything else, read the notes from your last 1:1. Not all of them. Just look for the sentence that ends with a comma rather than a period — the thought that didn't finish.
Last week you wrote "She's worried the PM is assigning work around her, will bring up next time." That's the loose thread. That's the first thing you're going to ask about today.
The loose thread is the single most valuable thing in a 1:1 prep, and it almost always takes less than a minute to find. If last week's notes are too thin to even surface one, that's a signal — not about last week's meeting, but about your note-taking. Fix that next week. For now, pick the best thing you can find and start there.
Minute 2 — Check what's changed on their side.
In sixty seconds you can scan the three places where the person you're meeting with has been leaving signals.
- Their recent PRs, tickets, or drafts. Not to review them. Just to have one specific, recent thing you noticed.
- The relevant Slack channel. One message. You're not fishing for gossip; you're calibrating. Is the energy up or down this week?
- Their last email or document you were cc'd on. Anything land differently than expected?
The goal of minute two is not research. It is to walk into the meeting with one specific, recent, concrete thing you can reference. "Saw you took the on-call for Priya this week — how'd that end up going?" is worth thirty times what "How's your week going?" is worth, because the person feels seen. And they feel seen because they were, in fact, seen.
Minute 3 — Ask yourself the hard question.
This is the minute that separates real prep from performance.
Ask yourself: Is there anything I've been avoiding telling this person?
Not "is there something I should tell them." Those are easy, and you'd remember. The question is whether there's a thing you've been avoiding. The feedback you've been meaning to give for two weeks. The honest answer to the question they asked last time that you fudged. The project change they don't know about yet.
If the answer is yes, today is the day. It will not get easier. You will not be less busy next Thursday. Waiting another week does not reduce the awkwardness; it multiplies it.
If the answer is no, move on. But don't skip the question. The question is the prep.
Minute 4 — Pick the one thing you want to happen.
Every good 1:1 has a center of gravity — a single thing you hope the meeting accomplishes. It does not have to be the most important thing in their work life. It has to be the most important thing you can realistically affect in 30 minutes.
Examples of good centers of gravity:
- "I want to understand whether she's actually excited about the new project or just being polite."
- "I want to give him the feedback that he's interrupting in design reviews and see how he takes it."
- "I want to check in on burnout. The last three weeks have been a lot."
- "I want to explicitly tell her I'm advocating for her promotion and see what she says."
Write the center of gravity down somewhere. Top of the agenda, in a sticky, on your hand — anywhere. When the meeting starts drifting toward a status update (and it will, because status updates are the path of least resistance), the center of gravity is what you steer back toward.
Minute 5 — Draft three questions, then cut two.
Three questions you could ask. Then — and this is the part most managers skip — cut it down to one.
One great question is worth more than three pretty good ones. Three pretty good ones turn the meeting into an interview. One great one turns the meeting into a conversation.
Great questions tend to be:
- Specific. Not "how's the project going" but "what's the part of the project that's been harder than you expected?"
- Opening. They invite a story, not a yes/no.
- Slightly risky for the asker. "Is there something I've been doing that's made this harder?" is better than "anything you need from me?" because the second question is hard to answer honestly and the first one makes honesty a little easier.
You're not running through a quiz. You're opening a door. One door at a time.
What to skip
For clarity on what a five-minute prep isn't:
- Don't write a long agenda. If the agenda is longer than four bullets, you're not preparing — you're defending against silence.
- Don't read performance data. You've already seen it. It's not going to get more useful in the next ninety seconds.
- Don't rehearse. Rehearsal is the enemy of the kind of meeting we're trying to have. Rehearsed sentences sound rehearsed; your report can tell.
- Don't copy last week's agenda and update it. This is how every 1:1 dies — by slow accretion.
The quiet sixth minute
If you have five minutes of prep, you don't need a sixth. But there's one thing I'd mention that technically happens before the five minutes: arrive with your notifications off. Ten seconds of closing Slack and putting your phone face down is worth more than two minutes of reading their last PR. Attention is what you're actually bringing to the meeting. Everything else is scaffolding.
—
Meetmora does minutes one and two for you automatically — pulls the loose thread from last week's notes and surfaces the specific, recent things happening on your direct report's side. Minutes three, four, and five are still on you.